“He was not a great guitarist, he was not a great singer. He kind of stumbled all over the stage”: Early Bob Dylan promoter and confidante Terri Thal talks Dylan’s classic Gaslight Café demo as it comes up for auction
With Dylan interest at a new high, Thal shares her story of discovering the star and making his first ever recording

Speaking to UCR in a timely new interview, with renewed Dylan interest at its peak following the recent A Complete Unknown biopic, early champion, manager and confidante Terri Thal tells all about her time discovering, promoting and nurturing the future folk star, and her creation of the first, and much-bootlegged Gaslight Café gig that put him on the map.
As an active participant in the '50s and '60s New York Greenwich Village scene, Thal had taken on the role of manager for her husband, Dave Van Ronk, and always had her ear to the ground for new talent.
Indeed, writing in his own Chronicles: Volume One, Dylan confirms the importance of Thal in his story. "Van Ronk's wife, Terri, definitely not a minor character, took care of Dave's bookings, especially out of town, and she began trying to help me out," he writes.
And it was Thal who first committed the young Dylan to tape, recording his Gaslight Café gig on 6 September 1961, that miraculously, and through countless bootlegs, still exists to this day, with the original tape currently up for auction.
Thal made the recording as ammo when pursuing bookings for the unknown up and comer.
“But the reaction that I got was pretty universally: 'Why should I hire this guy when I can hire Jack Elliot?,'" says Thal. “And Jack Elliott was a folksinger, also Jewish, from Brooklyn, who also changed his name, who sounded like Woody Guthrie… At that time a lot like Woody Guthrie… And the reaction I got was exactly the same. 'Why should I hire this kid when I can hire Jack Elliott?'"
Still, through Thal’s persistence, Dylan found his feet and while she would later graciously step aside, allowing Albert Grossman to propel Dylan’s career in the role of manager ("I know he can do much more for you than I can," Thal recalls saying to Dylan), her role in Dylan’s future has never been in doubt.
Get the MusicRadar Newsletter
Want all the hottest music and gear news, reviews, deals, features and more, direct to your inbox? Sign up here.
The Times They Are A-Changin’
“My first impression of Bob? I thought he was some kind of remarkable,” she recalls. “He was not a great guitarist, he was not a great singer. He kind of stumbled all over the stage. It took a while to realize that I was watching Charlie Chaplin, and there was something charming and memorable about the guy…
“I thought he was special. I thought he was distinctive… I took the tape to a recording studio, and I had a little cassette made or something like that, that I could physically carry to an out-of-town club.
"And that's why the thing got bootlegged… I assume the recording studio let somebody make copies, or a copy or whatever, of that tape, which ultimately was issued as a bootleg with dreadful sound.”
At the time of writing, the original demo - which auctioneers RR Auction claim boasts "clear, high-quality recordings of six early tracks" - is sitting at a price of $31,460, with 10 hours of bidding left. The six tracks in question are Old Man, He Was a Friend of Mine, Talkin’ Bear Mountain Picnic Massacre Blues, Song to Woody, Pretty Polly, and Car, Car.
If you want to get in on the auction action, head over to RRauction.com now.
Daniel Griffiths is a veteran journalist who has worked on some of the biggest entertainment, tech and home brands in the world. He's interviewed countless big names, and covered countless new releases in the fields of music, videogames, movies, tech, gadgets, home improvement, self build, interiors and garden design. He’s the ex-Editor of Future Music and ex-Group Editor-in-Chief of Electronic Musician, Guitarist, Guitar World, Computer Music and more. He renovates property and writes for MusicRadar.com.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

“It’s insane. He had two broken fingers on Friday’s show - and he played the gig”: Snow Patrol frontman Gary Lightbody praises “unbelievable” guitarist and keyboard player Johnny McDaid after he “wrecked” both his hands but never missed a show

“Tell me who your source pots are that keep giving you info about Oasis”: The 'confirmed' 2025 reunion line-up is out there and Liam Gallagher wants to know how it got leaked